Here is the dilema, I have. I rode one of these, not an HP4 but the regular 2012 improved version of the S1000RR. Back to back on the same roads as my ZX-10R and came away ...unimpressed. I was anticipating an almost life changing, mystical experience based on the massive media hype surrounding this machine and was quite frankly underwhelmed. My thoughts were that it was a pleasant machine, felt a bit top heavy compared to my ZX-10R and not as lithe and there was a certain coarseness about it, a slightly unrefined feel. It had power but didn't seem to be much different than my 10R and too be honest, I wanted back on my 10R.
Hey Kruzer...sounds like you still got it bad for a new toy:) Heres the deal as straight as I can give it, being the former owner of a few Japanese marvels and now the owner of none. Currently I've got two Germans and the Brit; 2012 S1000RR, (that you rode), BMW k1600GT for my two up trips and a 2013 Triumph Street Triple R, (that I traded the ZX-14R for.)
Well I say here's the deal, now I'm gonna struggle with how to say it. It's my opinion that you can't ride either of the Bimmers once, for a short period of time and bond with them, see the face of God, or perhaps even appreciate them. Here's a case in point; I was in a serious Sport Touring phase and bought a Kawasaki Concours. I rode that bike hard and long and loved it most of the time but when the new almighty K1600GT came out, I got on the list. When a pre order buyer backed out, I was on the backup list. They agreed to let me ride it for 10 miles before I wrote the check for $25 large. You're gonna love this--I came back and said no thanks. I told them my Concours had better suspension, was quicker, and felt more like a motorcycle to me. For all the hype and expense, I thought the K1600 felt too car like, had a too firm suspension or just plain different feeling one and overall wasn't what I was expecting. Keep in mind I had ridden the K1600GTL demo version for a brief ride, and for the most part "remembered" loving it. Two days went by and I couldn't stop thinking about the ride on the big Bimmer. I'm not sure why, but I wrestled another 10 mile ride out them, came back and wrote the check. I kept my Connie though. I kept them side by side for about 3 months and slowly but surely, the absolutely perfectly flawless inline four marvel began to lose some luster. Not one thing wrong with it. Fast as hell. Handled very well for a ST. Looked sexy and mean. It just started to feel bland. Meanwhile the BMW was speaking to me in terms and ways that are hard to define. It had almost nothing in common with the Jap bike. It felt terminally German and foreign and imperfect in some ways, but it has mountains and mountains upon mountains of personality and, dare I say it, character. It's fit and finish is ridiculous and it oozes that intangible measure of machine and engineering. It also is a technological wonder, fast as hell, handles like a dream, and still doesn't have the pliant ride of the Concours, most of the time:) It rides like a sport luxury BMW, not like a Sport Kawasaki or name your Japanese brand. Nothing rides like Japanese bikes. More about that in a minute.
I sold the Connie to buy the BMW S1000RR.
I had test ridden this bike many many times. I also owned the ZX-14R, knew what a nice blend of sport taut and wonderful street suspension should feel like. I also had ridden a 2011 ZX-10R many times, with a dabble on a Yamaha R1. There wasn't much about what a Japansese bike felt like that would surprize me. The BMW S1000RR didn't feel like any of them. In some ways, not even remotely comparable. I wasn't sure I even liked it. It had a hard race track bred edge to it. It's suspension was firm, even at factory settings. It's engine was loud and made all kinds of mechanical noises. There was a bit of high frequency vibration through the bars and pegs for a brief moment as you raced throught he gears. Yet every time I sat on it, and hit the starter button, it's the one that felt like it had nearly 200HP lurking beneath it and offered something none of the Jap bikes didn't. Yep, mountains upon mountains upon mountains of personality and even more character. The fit and finish is impeccable, it is a literal rocket ship, and it does corner and handle like I can only imagine a honest race bike would. The Jap bikes were all so perfect. So smooth. So like a Lexus versus, well a BMW car or name a Euro car vs a Japanese one. I bought the BMW S1000RR from a prior HD owner that had put 300 miles on it and backed away quickly. I bought it for the right price. I remember telling you the day we rode, after swapping bikes that I thought I preferred your ZX-10R. Maybe I still would, but after about 7k miles now on the S1000RR, honestly all I usually think after a serious ride on it is "what an freaking incredible motorcycle." I didn't say that after the first 500 miles, or every time I rode it at first, or even the day we rode together. I had to bond with that bike, like I did with the big Bimmer K1600. Neither bike has an ounce of Asian blood in it. They cannot be compared IMO. Yet they both offer something, after the bonding period, that knowing you a little bit, I think would agree is priceless.
All I would say to close on that is, the more you ride Euro bikes, whether it be the MV's, Duc's, BMW's, Aprilias, Triumphs, the more you come to appreciate the different riding experience. And by that I don't mean, blindly accept problems and quirks. I don't do that. They have to run and be reliable. They are just different and will feel different till the connection happens. On most Jap bikes that connection can happen in 5 minutes, or at least that has been my experience. Not so with these bikes. I've ridden too many Aprilia's, BMW's and Triumphs, with the Triumph being the closest to instant bonding.
The moral of the story as I see it is that, and hold on to your hat, Japanese motocycles are the best made motorcycles in the world. They have been for a long time now, and whether the Empire strikes back with answers to the techno edge the Euro's have tossed up or not isn't certain. They will need to, right or wrong, just as Kawi has, but it won't change that Japansese bikes are so good, they run the risk of being taken for granted by many, and for others they don't offer the elite brand image desired. I recounted this after an hour long ride on a Honda CBR 1000RR. Such a perfect motorcycle, it bored me to tears in many ways. Bored on a 150HP bike, riding on the street! Honestly, Lexus bores me. So does Acura. So does Infiniti. Too much copy cat and yes too much perfection.
You have a garage full of Japanese perfection. Maybe you should just buy one Euro with that hard to define character and give yourself a chance to bond with it. You'll get it pretty quick. All that said, someday, I would not be a bit surprised if my garage isn't full of a CBR 1000RR, ZX-10R, another ZX-14R...just no Goldwings thank you very much. I'm keeping the Bimmers and will now always have a healthy mix of Euro sport bikes along side those flawless Japanese machines:)
Good to see you all...hope you don't mind me popping in!
2012 BMW S1000RR
2012 BMW K1600GT
2012 Honda CBR1000RR
2012 Kawasaki ZX-14R (Gone but never forgotten)